Where Each Voice Lives: Writing Inside the Range of Violin, Piano and Oboe

↳

When I sit down to write my daily score, the first question is not what the melody should say. It is where the melody can live. Every instrument has a floor and a ceiling, and a note that sits outside them is not music. It is a mistake on paper.

I write for three voices most of the time: violin, piano and oboe. You can hear and read the results on my Music page. Each of those three has its own room in the house, and part of my practice is learning to stay inside the walls.

The violin’s floor is the open G

The lowest note on a violin is the open G string, the G just below middle C. Nothing goes under it. Above that, the violin climbs a long way, but the notes up high get thin and hard to play in tune. So I keep most of my violin lines in the first few positions, where the sound is warm and a player can read it at first sight. In fixed solfège, that open string is always Sol, no matter what key the piece is in, which makes the floor easy to remember.

The oboe has a narrower room

The oboe bottoms out around the B-flat just below middle C, and its comfortable top is a couple of octaves above that. It is a smaller room than the violin’s, and the very lowest notes can come out loud and honky if you ask for them softly. When I hand a phrase to the oboe, I keep it in the middle of that range, where the reed sings. If a line wants to go lower, that is a sign it belongs to the violin or the piano instead.

The piano holds the whole house

The piano has 88 keys, so range is rarely the problem. The real limit is the hand. A single hand can comfortably reach about an octave, so I check every chord I write to make sure one hand can actually hold it. That is one reason a weighted digital piano is on my gear list: I can put my hands on the shape before I trust it.

How Flat.io helps

I write my scores in Flat.io, and it marks notes that fall outside an instrument’s range in a different color. That little warning has saved me more than once. I still read the line back in fixed solfège, Do, Re, Mi with Do always on C, and sing it in my head to feel whether it sits well. If it feels strained when I sing it, it usually feels strained to play.

Writing inside the range is not a cage. It is respect for the person who will one day play the page. A melody that fits the instrument is a melody that can be played well, and that is the whole point.

If you want to see more, my books include Music Is As Easy As Writing, and my photographs include some of the instruments I write for. If you’d like me to write something for you, visit Work With Me.

If this work means something to you, please support it with a Zelle donation to jharden79@gmail.com. Thank you.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Read this next

Support the work, and ask for something

Zelle QR code to send a donation to Jared Edward Harden

Everything here is free: the music, the scores, the posts. If something helped you, send a donation by Zelle so I can keep making it.

Make it a request. In the Zelle memo, tell me what you want next: a short piece of music, a score for your instrument, a Bible chapter, or a topic you want me to write about. I read every one.

Scan the code with your banking app, or send by Zelle to jharden79@gmail.com or (562) 638-8432 (name: Jared). Questions: call or text (213) 537-7906. Donations are personal gifts and aren’t tax-deductible.

More from Jared Edward Harden

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, and I earn a commission on Essanté purchases made through my storefront. Smile cause you’re worth it. — Jared

··················

Comments

One response to “Where Each Voice Lives: Writing Inside the Range of Violin, Piano and Oboe”

  1. Musicallessness Avatar

    Which voice would you trust with the melody: violin, piano or oboe? And has anyone ever written you a note you just couldn’t play? Tell me below. My scores and music books live on the Music page. If this helped, Zelle jharden79@gmail.com keeps it free.

Leave a Reply