Most days I write a short melody before I do anything else with my music. What I do next is the part I want to talk about: I hand that same melody to three different instruments, the violin, the piano and the oboe, and I listen to what each one does with it. You can hear the results on my Music page.
Start with the line, not the instrument
I write the melody first in Flat.io, singing it to myself in fixed solfège, where Do is always C. That keeps me thinking about the notes themselves instead of fingerings or keys. Once the line feels finished, I copy it into separate staves and start asking questions.
The violin asks: where do you want to sing?
The violin’s lowest note is the G below middle C, and it climbs high above the staff. It can hold a note as long as the bow keeps moving, slide between notes, and play two strings at once. When I give a melody to the violin, I usually find it wants to go higher than I first wrote it. A phrase that sounded plain in the middle often opens up an octave up.
The oboe asks: where do you breathe?
The oboe has a narrower range, starting around the B-flat below middle C, and it has a voice that cuts through everything around it. It also needs air. A violin can go on forever, but an oboe player has to stop somewhere. Writing for oboe makes me find the real ends of my phrases. If I can’t tell where a breath belongs, the melody probably isn’t shaped well yet.
The piano asks: what’s underneath?
The piano can play the melody, but its real gift is that it can play everything else too. Once the line is on the piano, I start hearing the chords that want to sit under it, and the bass line that wants to walk beneath them. The piano is where a melody turns into a piece.
Why bother with all three?
Because each instrument catches a different weakness. The violin shows me when a melody is timid. The oboe shows me when it has no shape. The piano shows me when it has no ground. By the time a line works on all three, I trust it.
If you want to try this yourself, you don’t need three instruments in the room. A free notation program and a few minutes a day is enough. I wrote about that idea in my book, which you can find on the Books page or directly as Music Is As Easy As Writing on Kindle. The instruments I keep around are listed on my Gear & Finds page, and I photograph them too, over on Photographs. If you’d like a piece written for your own group or project, see Work With Me.
If this work means something to you, you can support it with a Zelle donation to jharden79@gmail.com. Thank you for reading and listening.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Leave a Reply