Same Notes, Different Weather: Writing in a Minor Key

↳

People hear a minor key and call it sad. Sometimes it is. But most of the time when I write in minor, I’m not reaching for sad. I’m reaching for weather. A cloudy afternoon. A street after dark. Something with a little more shadow in it than a sunny major tune.

Here’s the part that surprised me when I first understood it: A minor and C major use the exact same seven notes. No sharps, no flats. Do, Re, Mi, Fa, Sol, La, Si — all white keys on the piano. What changes is where the music calls home.

Home is a different note

I use fixed solfège, so Do is always C, no matter the key. That makes minor easy to see on the page. In A minor, the line keeps circling back to La. It starts near La, leans on Mi, and lands on La at the end. Same notes as C major, but the center of gravity moved two steps down, and the whole piece feels different because of it.

In Flat.io I set the key signature first, then I listen. If the melody keeps wanting to rest on Do, it’s major whether I meant it or not. If it keeps sinking back to La, it’s minor. I let the line tell me.

The one note I borrow

Plain minor can feel like it never quite arrives. So near the end of a phrase I’ll often raise Sol to Sol sharp, one half step under La. That little lift pulls hard toward home and makes the last note land with a click. It’s an old trick, and it works on all three of my instruments.

How each instrument wears it

The violin takes to minor naturally. Its open strings are G, D, A and E, and A minor sits right under the fingers. The oboe has a reedy, singing voice that already carries a bit of longing, so a minor line on oboe doesn’t need much help. On piano, minor lets the left hand hold low, dark chords while the right hand sings over them. Same key, three different moods.

Why bother switching

Writing a score every day, it’s easy to fall into one color. Moving between major and minor keeps my ear honest. It also matches what I see. A lot of my photographs are night streets and shaded trees, and minor is the sound of those pictures to me.

If you want to try it, take any simple tune you know in C major and end it on La instead of Do. Then raise one Sol to Sol sharp right before the end. Play it back and listen to what changed. That’s the whole idea, and it’s the kind of thing I walk through in my book Music Is As Easy As Writing.

You can hear and see the daily scores on my Music page. My other books are on the Books page, the instruments and tools I use are on the Gear & Finds page, and if you’d like a custom piece or other help, see Work With Me.

If this work means something to you, please support it with a Zelle donation to jharden79@gmail.com. Every bit keeps the scores coming.

Read this next

Support the work, and ask for something

Zelle QR code to send a donation to Jared Edward Harden

Everything here is free: the music, the scores, the posts. If something helped you, send a donation by Zelle so I can keep making it.

Make it a request. In the Zelle memo, tell me what you want next: a short piece of music, a score for your instrument, a Bible chapter, or a topic you want me to write about. I read every one.

Scan the code with your banking app, or send by Zelle to jharden79@gmail.com or (562) 638-8432 (name: Jared). Questions: call or text (213) 537-7906. Donations are personal gifts and aren’t tax-deductible.

More from Jared Edward Harden

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, and I earn a commission on Essanté purchases made through my storefront. Smile cause you’re worth it. — Jared

··················

Comments

One response to “Same Notes, Different Weather: Writing in a Minor Key”

  1. Musicallessness Avatar

    Quick one for you: what’s a song in a minor key that hits you every time, even though it’s the same notes as a happy one? Want the key-signature side of this? Read Sharps, Flats and Fixed Do. If this helped, Zelle jharden79@gmail.com keeps it free.

Leave a Reply