Declared in Ink: Every Religion Declares War — and the Watchtower’s “Neutrality” Is Lukewarm

↳

Almost every major religion has declared war, blessed it, and later helped end it. The Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society, the organization behind the Jehovah’s Witnesses (jw.org, formerly watchtower.org), says it stands above all that. It calls itself neutral. I went through the record, and this is my verdict: that neutrality is lukewarm, and the Watchtower declares its own war in ink.

This post is a summary of my new book, Declared in Ink: Religion, War, and the Lukewarm Neutrality of the Watchtower.

How religions declare war

  • Christianity: Augustine and Aquinas wrote “just war” rules: lawful authority, just cause, right intention. Pope Urban II launched the First Crusade in 1095. In World War I, German soldiers wore Gott mit uns (“God with us”) on their belt buckles while British clergy preached a crusade.
  • Islam: Classical law set rules for armed jihad, which tradition calls the lesser jihad, compared with the greater jihad against one’s own soul.
  • Judaism: Maimonides distinguished commanded war, such as defending against an attacker, from discretionary war, which a king could declare only with the Sanhedrin’s approval.
  • Hinduism: In the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna tells Arjuna that fighting a righteous war (dharma yuddha) is his duty.
  • Buddhism: Japan’s Zen establishment backed the imperial war machine through World War II, and monks in Myanmar and Sri Lanka have pushed violence in modern times.
  • Sikhism: Guru Gobind Singh taught that when every other means has failed, it is righteous to draw the sword.

How religions end war

The church’s Peace of God and Truce of God (975 and 1095) protected civilians and banned fighting on holy days. The Prophet Muhammad agreed to a ten-year truce at al-Hudaybiyah in 628. The Peace of Westphalia in 1648 ended Europe’s Thirty Years’ War of religion. A Catholic community mediated Mozambique’s 1992 peace accord, and the Vatican kept Argentina and Chile from war in 1984.

The ones who refused

To be accurate, not every other religion preaches war. Quakers, Mennonites, Amish, Brethren and Jains reject war completely.

Jehovah’s Witnesses refused too, and paid for it. The U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum reports that at least 273 were executed for refusing to serve in Hitler’s army, and about 1,400 died in camps and prisons, where they wore the purple triangle. I honor that.

So why “lukewarm”?

“Because thou art lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will spue thee out of my mouth.” — Revelation 3:16

  1. They are not pacifists. Their own October 2022 Watchtower says God doesn’t authorize humans to fight today, but that he will destroy his enemies in a future war, Armageddon.
  2. They stay neutral toward injustice (they don’t vote, protest or speak against genocide) while relying on the same governments’ courts for protection.
  3. They were listed with the UN as an affiliated organization from 1992 until The Guardian exposed it in October 2001, while teaching that the UN is the “scarlet-colored wild beast.”

War declared in ink

The Watchtower teaches that “Babylon the Great,” meaning every other religion, will be destroyed by the world’s political powers led by the UN, and that Armageddon will wipe out the rest of Satan’s world. Its 1957 article “Use Theocratic War Strategy” calls its own work a theocratic warfare. In the 1930s, Witnesses marched with signs reading “Religion Is a Snare and a Racket.”

Slander, lies and theft: the charges

  • Lies: The end was predicted for 1914, then 1925, then 1975. In 1980 the Watchtower itself admitted that its 1975 statements made the end sound like a probability.
  • Strategy: The same 1957 article teaches that it is proper to hide the truth from “enemies.”
  • Slander: The July 15, 2011 Watchtower called apostates “mentally diseased.”
  • Theft (allegation, not a court finding): Critics call the 2014 transfer of Kingdom Hall funds and properties to the central organization a property grab. On the record: a California jury found the Watchtower negligent in the Candace Conti child-abuse case, and Australia’s Royal Commission found that none of 1,006 alleged abusers in the Witnesses’ files had been reported to police.

What they say back

To be fair: Norway’s Supreme Court ruled for the Witnesses in April 2026, they eased their shunning rules in 2024, and their court cases have expanded religious freedom for everyone. The book covers both sides.

Why this is personal

I live with autism (ASD), ADHD and schizophrenia. I’m on disability and on medical suspension from trucking. I believe racism helped push me into early retirement. So when an organization calls the people who leave it “mentally diseased,” I don’t hear theology. I hear the oldest trick there is. A diagnosis doesn’t erase a witness.

Get the book, and support the work

Read Declared in Ink free right now (the whole book is embedded above, or download the PDF). It’s coming to Kindle next. Then read my other books:

Keep reading the Bible chapter by chapter and my daily music scores at Musicallessness.com, and visit my Musicallessness Blog and Portfolio.

Keep reading: The Anxiety of Sins · Denying Is Not Lying · Why I Wrote Gravely Disabled · A Diagnosis Is Not a Destiny · The Bible, chapter by chapter

If this was worth your time, send a donation by Zelle to jharden79@gmail.com or (562) 638-8432. No publisher pays for this. You do.

Sources: jw.org on war · Watchtower, Oct. 2022 · Watchtower, May 1, 1957 · Watchtower, July 15, 2011 · USHMM · The Guardian, 2001 · Reveal on the Conti case · Aquinas on war · Peace of Westphalia · Norway Supreme Court ruling (HRWF). The full source list is in the book.

Read this next

Support the work, and ask for something

Zelle QR code to send a donation to Jared Edward Harden

Everything here is free: the music, the scores, the posts. If something helped you, send a donation by Zelle so I can keep making it.

Make it a request. In the Zelle memo, tell me what you want next: a short piece of music, a score for your instrument, a Bible chapter, or a topic you want me to write about. I read every one.

Scan the code with your banking app, or send by Zelle to jharden79@gmail.com or (562) 638-8432 (name: Jared). Questions: call or text (213) 537-7906. Donations are personal gifts and aren’t tax-deductible.

More from Jared Edward Harden

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, and I earn a commission on Essanté purchases made through my storefront. Smile cause you’re worth it. — Jared

··················

Comments

4 responses to “Declared in Ink: Every Religion Declares War — and the Watchtower’s “Neutrality” Is Lukewarm”

  1. […] my new book, Declared in Ink, free: the full sourced case, with both sides. Or read the summary post on Musicallessness.com. Then try Gravely Disabled: A Memoir, all my free books and my Kindle […]

  2. Musicallessness Avatar

    Which part of this matched what you were taught, and which part surprised you? Share below. For why rigid systems tend to crack, read Absolute Zero. If this helped, Zelle jharden79@gmail.com keeps it free.

  3. […] reading: Declared in Ink: the full book summary · The Anxiety of Sins · The Bible, chapter by chapter · […]

  4. […] reading: Declared in Ink · The Anxiety of Sins · I Don’t Know Who I Am Without You · All my […]

Leave a Reply